Details

    • Type: New Feature New Feature
    • Status: Open
    • Priority: Critical Critical
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Affects Version/s: None
    • Fix Version/s: None
    • Component/s: Checklistbank
    • Labels:

      Description

      There are indeed higher rank homonyms existing at the same rank within the same kingdom that we need to deal with. The animal family Axiidae for example is a moth family and a crab. Even though the moth family is nowadays considered a synonym of Cimeliidae both should coexist in the backbone. See also http://dev.gbif.org/issues/browse/CLB-72

      This requires a change of the IdLookup implementation to also consider the classification underneath kingdoms or we must use authors for higher taxa, at least families.

      The example Axiidae families we used to have are:
      http://www.gbif.org/species/8024
      http://www.gbif.org/species/8026

        Gliffy Diagrams

        Issue Links

          Activity

          Show
          Markus Döring added a comment - added to patch list: https://github.com/gbif/backbone-patch/commit/7d0b4c268bca5a02c56403140985e4aa596cca44
          Hide
          Markus Döring added a comment - - edited

          Attaching a list of all CoL homonyms down to genus rank. There are a few family homonyms existing:

          123627359       SUPERFAMILY     Axioidea        123786291       SUPERFAMILY     Axioidea
          123786291       SUPERFAMILY     Axioidea        123627359       SUPERFAMILY     Axioidea
          123786292       FAMILY  Axiidae 123627360       FAMILY  Axiidae
          123627360       FAMILY  Axiidae 123786292       FAMILY  Axiidae
          123815890       FAMILY  Bonelliidae     123817301       FAMILY  Bonelliidae
          123817301       FAMILY  Bonelliidae     123815890       FAMILY  Bonelliidae
          123769236       FAMILY  Cepheidae       123808377       FAMILY  Cepheidae
          123808377       FAMILY  Cepheidae       123769236       FAMILY  Cepheidae
          123599692       FAMILY  Chilodontidae   123792049       FAMILY  Chilodontidae
          123792049       FAMILY  Chilodontidae   123599692       FAMILY  Chilodontidae
          123815974       FAMILY  Echiuridae      123817255       FAMILY  Echiuridae
          123817255       FAMILY  Echiuridae      123815974       FAMILY  Echiuridae
          123828420       FAMILY  Lagynidae       123830425       FAMILY  Lagynidae
          123830425       FAMILY  Lagynidae       123828420       FAMILY  Lagynidae
          123844211       FAMILY  Lichenotheliaceae       123841872       FAMILY  Lichenotheliaceae
          123841872       FAMILY  Lichenotheliaceae       123844211       FAMILY  Lichenotheliaceae
          123790536       FAMILY  Personidae      123620363       FAMILY  Personidae
          123620363       FAMILY  Personidae      123790536       FAMILY  Personidae
          123611656       FAMILY  Sagittariidae   123827056       FAMILY  Sagittariidae
          123827056       FAMILY  Sagittariidae   123611656       FAMILY  Sagittariidae
          123844125       FAMILY  Seuratiaceae    123838007       FAMILY  Seuratiaceae
          123838007       FAMILY  Seuratiaceae    123844125       FAMILY  Seuratiaceae
          123842316       FAMILY  Strigulaceae    123840300       FAMILY  Strigulaceae
          123840300       FAMILY  Strigulaceae    123842316       FAMILY  Strigulaceae
          123816035       FAMILY  Urechidae       123817243       FAMILY  Urechidae
          123817243       FAMILY  Urechidae       123816035       FAMILY  Urechidae
          

          Some of these do not seem correct, others do.
          E.g. family Strigulaceae is twice in Ascomycota and once in an unplaced order. Very likely this is the same

          Show
          Markus Döring added a comment - - edited Attaching a list of all CoL homonyms down to genus rank. There are a few family homonyms existing: 123627359 SUPERFAMILY Axioidea 123786291 SUPERFAMILY Axioidea 123786291 SUPERFAMILY Axioidea 123627359 SUPERFAMILY Axioidea 123786292 FAMILY Axiidae 123627360 FAMILY Axiidae 123627360 FAMILY Axiidae 123786292 FAMILY Axiidae 123815890 FAMILY Bonelliidae 123817301 FAMILY Bonelliidae 123817301 FAMILY Bonelliidae 123815890 FAMILY Bonelliidae 123769236 FAMILY Cepheidae 123808377 FAMILY Cepheidae 123808377 FAMILY Cepheidae 123769236 FAMILY Cepheidae 123599692 FAMILY Chilodontidae 123792049 FAMILY Chilodontidae 123792049 FAMILY Chilodontidae 123599692 FAMILY Chilodontidae 123815974 FAMILY Echiuridae 123817255 FAMILY Echiuridae 123817255 FAMILY Echiuridae 123815974 FAMILY Echiuridae 123828420 FAMILY Lagynidae 123830425 FAMILY Lagynidae 123830425 FAMILY Lagynidae 123828420 FAMILY Lagynidae 123844211 FAMILY Lichenotheliaceae 123841872 FAMILY Lichenotheliaceae 123841872 FAMILY Lichenotheliaceae 123844211 FAMILY Lichenotheliaceae 123790536 FAMILY Personidae 123620363 FAMILY Personidae 123620363 FAMILY Personidae 123790536 FAMILY Personidae 123611656 FAMILY Sagittariidae 123827056 FAMILY Sagittariidae 123827056 FAMILY Sagittariidae 123611656 FAMILY Sagittariidae 123844125 FAMILY Seuratiaceae 123838007 FAMILY Seuratiaceae 123838007 FAMILY Seuratiaceae 123844125 FAMILY Seuratiaceae 123842316 FAMILY Strigulaceae 123840300 FAMILY Strigulaceae 123840300 FAMILY Strigulaceae 123842316 FAMILY Strigulaceae 123816035 FAMILY Urechidae 123817243 FAMILY Urechidae 123817243 FAMILY Urechidae 123816035 FAMILY Urechidae Some of these do not seem correct, others do. E.g. family Strigulaceae is twice in Ascomycota and once in an unplaced order. Very likely this is the same
          Hide
          Markus Döring added a comment -

          Authorship for families would be good to have. It helps to disambiguate homonyms which are not very frequent but do exist more than initially thought

          Show
          Markus Döring added a comment - Authorship for families would be good to have. It helps to disambiguate homonyms which are not very frequent but do exist more than initially thought

            People

            • Assignee:
              Unassigned
              Reporter:
              Markus Döring
            • Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              1 Start watching this issue

              Dates

              • Created:
                Updated: